Kill la Kill: Fashion, Fascism, and a Heroine’s Shonen

Kill la Kill is a bizarre combination of disparate elements.  It follows the genre expectations of Shonen manga, with semi-constant fighting, growing friendships, and that strange running theme of turning one’s previously defeated foes into new allies, but it replaces the normally male leads with female ones and does the same for many of the villains as well.  Despite this refreshing gender-reversal, the show still drips with male gaze and fan service; there are a few moments where the show mentions how ridiculous this is (as the protagonist rages against the stupidity of her outfit), but Kill la Kill still falls into the same visual patterns and doesn’t really change that paradigm.

Kill la Kill (careful, spoilers) excels at the absurd, as one might expect from the same creative directors who brought us Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann, and offers a look at fascism and fashion.  Or maybe it’s fascism by means of fashion?  The story begins as one young woman’s quest to avenge her father’s murder, as she sets herself against the leader of Honnouji Academy, whom she suspects of having arranged his death.  This school is a fascist dictatorship in which power-augmenting school uniforms are used both as a reward and as a means of control.  Things only get weirder from there.  I think it’s quite enjoyable in the end, but you should probably read at least some of my mixed feelings below.

Before I go any further, I should warn you: there’s an early scene in which the protagonist is assaulted by newly found sentient clothing.  I’m not saying this to show off how crazy the show is.  Even though there’s no explicitly sexual content to the scene, it’s definitely nonconsensual and made me deeply uncomfortable even as I gaped in shock at how ridiculous the idea of it was.  Looking back, I suppose I can see how it fits with all of the later themes of the show, and I can even accept that there is some merit to including it, but I thought you should know.  Though I like it as a whole there are parts of this show which are very uncomfortable.*

I feel that I should give credit to the show’s creators for bringing up the problematic nature of ridiculous fan service and absurdly scanty battle-clothes, but I don’t think I can go much further than that on that front; despite mentioning the problem, they’re perfectly happy to leave it a central place in their setting.  I’m glad that at least someone in anime is willing to have characters who are perfectly aware of how stupidly inadequate fan-service-oriented women’s combat uniforms are.  I just wish that they could do more than mention it and then continue to exploit it relentlessly.

On the plus side, everyone who likes seeing scantily clad men will also find some good eye-candy in this show.  While the mostly naked men aren’t anywhere near as frequent as the scantily clad female characters, they are a consistently recurring theme.  I can’t say that their presence magically makes all the previous blatant fan service totally ok, but I’m far more willing to accept the fan service when it clearly goes both ways.  Without spoiling too much, I think I can also say that this is the only setting I’ve seen in which much of the fan service has deeper in-setting rationalizations that more or less explain why you get to see so much skin.

I know I mentioned earlier that this is basically a Shonen genre adventure with all-female leads, but I didn’t mention one of the fascinating corollaries: Kill la Kill passes the Bechdel test with flying colors.  You routinely have scenes in which two female characters talk with each other about the villainess, for example, which is nearly unheard of for this genre.  Given that the Shonen genre is generally the province of young boys, I’m pretty happy with this state of things.

So, in conclusion?  I think Kill la Kill is an over-the-top, absurd, and rather enjoyable show.  Where Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann felt like an enthusiastic parody of the Shonen genre that was still definitely in the genre, Kill la Kill feels like a successful experiment in expanding the range of the Shonen genre to include female protagonists and main supporting characters.  I don’t think it accomplishes all that much in the way of changing the conversation around fan service and scanty fighting uniforms, but it does (eventually) engage in equal opportunity fan service with great aplomb.  Better yet, it manages to be a good show despite its uncomfortable moments.  There’s also more to be said about the amalgamation of fashion and fascism, but I don’t want to ruin anything for you.  Speaking of not ruining anything for you, if you do watch the show be sure not to skip through the end credits.  You’ll miss a considerable number of small details if you do.

 

*I’m not talking about Gamagoori

Advertisements

One response to “Kill la Kill: Fashion, Fascism, and a Heroine’s Shonen

  1. You’ve not thought this through or even what drama is about. KLK isn’t a good show “despite” it’s uncomfortable moments, it’s a good show because of them, and because they serve a meaningful purpose rather than (just) titillation.

    The protagonist is a hero/ine because she overcomes terrifying conflicts and challenges. She couldn’t do this if there were none. I’d suggest that the first scene with Senkowitz (sp?) is supposed to represent the onset of puberty – powerful changes in your body which maybe very scary and have consequences you don’t waht, and which you haven’t asked for. The sailor suit is fed on *blood* and transforms her body body, yes? In fact, the show is an inversion of a lot of conventional fairy tales in that it’s a story about a woman who conquers the challenges of puberty without haveing to rely on a man to do so.

    As for the T&A, they’re there… but they’re very rarely sexy. They’re more often used for comic effect or poresented in a desexualized manner – close-up shots of the two sisters are often presented in super-wideangle and inredibly distorted to emphasize a non-sexual body part. They’re shot like mecha, not pornstars.

    And talking of mecha, one sister is clearly the genderbend version of Simon from Gurren Laggan, and the other Rossiu – both physically and mentally! And the Simon analog has a mentor character who looks like Simon’s menot, Kamina. And Simon’s main costume for GL left him literally topless other than a cloak and sunglasses. So throwing in the Nudist Beach scenes – and that the male mentor chracter is the one who strikes psexually provocative poses – and what we have is a story about female empowerment that assumes that both men and women find are attracted to heroic bare flesh of their preferred gender. You may or may not like this, but it’s not misogynistic or especially about the “male gaze.”

    So in summary: drama is about conflict. If you’re going to have a hyper-dramatic action show that uses external events to reprsent the internal challenges of puberty, then you’re going to scenes where the protagonist is faced with what at least looks like the threat of sexually related violence. Taking this option off the able means you can not tell stories that are about women faced with this challenge. What would have been awful would have been if the scene had been made titillating – but it wasn’t.

What do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s