I’ve come around to believing that OSR games are often a better entry point to playing RPGs—OSR here meaning “old school revival” or “old school renaissance”, a modern game in the style of early D&D. Most OSR games have fewer rules and systems for new players to learn. They have fewer special abilities to remember, creating fewer opportunities for choice-paralysis. Starting a game is also often faster, as making a new character is usually simple and often highly randomized. Finally, like D&D 5e, the genres delivered by OSR games are usually in line with novice players’ expectations of fantasy tabletop roleplaying games.
This does all vary by system. It also varies by how much work the storyteller does for the players before the game. So why am I confident that OSR games are, on average, more accessible than D&D 5e?
Shouldn’t the newer game be better?
Lol no I’m not going to tell you the solution is one-size-fits-all. It depends!
But the newer game is not always better.
Tabletop roleplaying games (TTRPGs, or simply RPGs) are just ways to play make believe. These games use rules to make sure that everyone agrees about what is happening, or knows whom to ask when a decision is needed. Playing make believe is easy. Playing RPGs can be too.
Yes, some of us lose easy access to playing make believe (or even using our imaginations) as we get older. I’ve felt that myself.
Make believe is, however, a simple and accessible pastime. Most people have played make believe at some point in their lives. Many people are able to reconnect with that and play make believe with friends when they sit down and play a TTRPG. So what’s stopping people from playing any old RPG?
Complexity!
How many rules are there? How hard is it to make a new character? How easily can you make a new character that feels fun and fulfilling to play? How likely are you to make a new character that isn’t good at what you want them to do well? How many moving parts or resources do players need to track? Do the game’s rules cover every situation, or every possible scenario? Can your character quickly fail at doing something you, the player, can easily imagine just because you don’t know how the rules work? Do you need to remember all your special abilities (or all your foes’) just to feel competent? Does forgetting a few non-obvious rules make you more likely to get your character killed?
Did that pile of questions feel overwhelming? Imagine how a new player feels.
Here’s my take: the closer playing a game system feels to playing make believe, the better an entry point the system is for new players. Fewer rules good, more rules bad. Players should be able to imagine a course of action, describe it, and then do it (or at least feel good about trying to do it).
Does that mean you NEED a rules-light game? Is a barebones OSR game the best possible entry point for new players?
Again, no. With a sufficiently helpful and knowledgeable storyteller, you can have this experience in ANY game system. The storyteller matters more than the game system.
But more complex game systems are harder to run smoothly while preserving the player’s sense of agency. Specifically, the more special abilities or extra rules or limited bonus resources your character has, the harder it is to feel like you’re the one in charge of your character when someone else is trying to translate your imagination into action. That goes double when you’re dealing with something like magic, where a player’s imagination might not agree with the game system’s rules and limitations. There’s a reason experienced players will recommend against playing a wizard or sorcerer or cleric in D&D 5e for your first game. Those character classes are more complex than a fighter or barbarian, and that complexity grows significantly as your character advances.
I’m not arguing that OSR games are objectively superior to D&D 5e. I’m saying that game systems have different implicit expectations of rule-mastery on the part of the players. Generally speaking, the more complex the system, the higher those implicit expectations are. OSR games, as far as I can tell, simply tend to have less complexity and a lower barrier to entry than more complex systems like 5e.
There are clear exceptions, however.
Remember when I said that the storyteller matters more than the system? If your storyteller is more comfortable running a larger and more complex system than running an OSR system, play what your storyteller is comfortable running. A system’s simplicity will not cover for an uncomfortable storyteller, and an extremely comfortable storyteller can often cover for a complex system.
It also helps if your storyteller has thought through how to introduce new players to the game. If your storyteller hasn’t thought that through, make sure your storyteller reads the Teaching the Game section of the Monsterhearts book (starting p131 of the first edition). That section lays out an extremely clear approach which can be generalized to other systems. Ideally your storyteller is both comfortable with their system of choice, and has a clear methodology for introducing new players to the system in stages.
A final strike against OSR: many OSR systems suffer from worse editing and organization than a more mainstream game like 5e. This often means that inexperienced storytellers will feel comfortable with 5e than with OSR, because they can more easily find and reference what they want when they want it. I think this is an underappreciated obstacle to running many OSR systems.
Despite this, I still believe that OSR games are (often unintentionally) more accessible to novice players. OSR games’ rules are usually less complex than 5e’s rules. Finally, as I mentioned at the top, it also helps that most OSR games focus on the kinds of stories that new players might expect (dungeon delving and high adventure), even if an OSR game is more likely than 5e to kill the player characters. This combination of fewer rules and a familiar genre is part of what I see as OSR’s edge over other relatively simple games like Spirit of the Century or Monsterhearts or Unknown Armies 3rd Ed.—those other games may also be accessible to new players, but I suspect fewer people are familiar with playing make believe in their genres (pulp, teen monster romance & horror, and postmodern horror).
So. If you’re trying to introduce some new players to RPGs, might I recommend trying out a few different OSR games? They might offer just what your players are looking for.