Are OSR games the best RPGs for new players?

I’ve come around to believing that OSR games are often a better entry point to playing RPGs—OSR here meaning “old school revival” or “old school renaissance”, a modern game in the style of early D&D. Most OSR games have fewer rules and systems for new players to learn. They have fewer special abilities to remember, creating fewer opportunities for choice-paralysis. Starting a game is also often faster, as making a new character is usually simple and often highly randomized. Finally, like D&D 5e, the genres delivered by OSR games are usually in line with novice players’ expectations of fantasy tabletop roleplaying games.

This does all vary by system. It also varies by how much work the storyteller does for the players before the game. So why am I confident that OSR games are, on average, more accessible than D&D 5e?

Shouldn’t the newer game be better?

Continue reading →